Now offering slices ALL DAY!


  That's Amore Pizza has moved! Now located at 105 N. Main Street, Crystal Lake, est. May 2014. You can choose take-out, delivery, or dine in our small casual dining area, which has 24 seats. We opened February of 2012 in a quaint storefront on the southeast corner of the intersection of Routes 31 and 176, the once infamous 5-way! We still offer authentic New York style, hand-tossed, thin crust PIE. We are open for lunch and offer pizza by the slice, all day long! Every slice comes with one of our FAMOUS garlic knots. Two garlic knots come with every pizza. Enjoy appetizers, sandwiches, pasta dinners, and salads including BBQ chicken, Buffalo Chicken, and Caprese – tomato, fresh basil, & fresh mozzarella – so savory and satisfying. A must is to taste Tom’s homemade meatballs, Italian beef, and marinara, and don’t forget his delicious Chili! …recipes perfected over many years. Another hidden gem is the meatball on a knot sandwich, at $1.79 it‘s a lunchtime favorite. We also do catering!

Order classic cheese pie or splurge on one of our EIGHTEEN specialty pizzas, and be assured you are going to come back for more! Western BBQ, Cassie’s Cali, L.A. SMOG, Dino’s Special, Popeye’s, and the current favorite... Margherita, are a few of our delicious and unique offerings. You can also choose from over fifteen FRESH toppings for a build-your-own favorite combination. We also offer a personal 10” gluten-free crust to build your own masterpiece!

Now, That's Amore!

Tom and Kim Nestelberger


That's Amore Pizza Reviews